Broken Statue: American Liberty and the Assault on Immigrants

Posted On
Posted By KFJ


Liberty means freedom. Freedom is not about borders, passports, driving licenses, tax stubs and censuses. Freedom is not about race, ethnicity, religion, nationality, or one’s economic worth. Freedom is the feeling of being free. Freedom is the pursuit of life and happiness.

Recently I have been thinking about a sweet little children’s book called The Statue of Liberty by Lucille Recht Penner. The author writes, “A lady stands in New York Harbor. She is as tall as a skyscraper. She is called the Statue of Liberty. “Liberty” means freedom. All over the world, people dreamed of coming to America to find freedom. People came by ship. The trip took many days. Men, women, and children were crowded together. They were tired, hungry, and scared. Suddenly they saw the lady! They had reached America at last. Now they knew they were free. People cried for joy. The Statue of Liberty was a present from the people of France to the people of the United States.” 

It may be a simple children’s book but the most profound messages are so often encapsulated in the most unassuming forms. The question that this book asks all Americans to think about is why France gave us that statue in the first place. Here is what I think. I think they gave this gift to our nation because they admired what America could become. Much more grandly, France wanted that statue to represent the dawn of a new kind of opportunity in the human experience. They wanted it to be a beacon of faith and hopefulness for all nations- and a permanent monument to the brotherhood and sisterhood of common people wherever they are in solidarity. In the memorable words of Emma Lazarus, “Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free.”

These powerful words are being sucked dry of their meaning by the Trump regime. Today, despite President Trump’s confounding revision of history regarding DACA, the fact remains that he alone is responsible for putting the program on life support. In fact, from day one his administration has made it a priority to intimidate, belittle, undermine and even physically harm immigrants through legislation. Rather than extending a hand to the tired, he has ripped it away and shoved them back towards the ledge of despair. Rather than welcoming the poor and huddled masses yearning to be free, he has smeared them for their poverty and mocked their desire for a better life. From authorizing Gestapo like raids by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) to implementing unconstitutional travel bans on Muslim refugees, President Trump has shamelessly dismantled the American promise and forever tarnished the symbolic beauty of France’s most treasured bequest to our country-the Statue of Liberty.

All over the world people still dream of coming to America. But when they arrive now, there will no longer be someone special waiting for them. She used to stand in New York Harbor, lighting their way home.   


George Cassidy Payne is a freelance writer, adjunct professor of philosophy and domestic violence counselor. He lives and works in Rochester, NY.

Related Post